NY City FC - Columbus Crew

25'

Maxime Chanot (NY City FC)

36'

Corey Ashe (Columbus Crew)

36'

Harrison Afful (Columbus Crew)

45'

John Mendoza (NY City FC)

59'

Ola Kamara (Columbus Crew)

64'

Ethan Finlay (Columbus Crew)

64'

Christian Martínez (Columbus Crew)

66'

John Mendoza (NY City FC)

66'

Khiry Shelton (NY City FC)

73'

Andrea Pirlo (NY City FC)

73'

Frank Lampard (NY City FC)

75'

Jack Harrison (NY City FC)

76'

Federico Higuaín (Columbus Crew)

76'

Conor Casey (Columbus Crew)

77'

Khiry Shelton (NY City FC)

79'

Tony Tchani (Columbus Crew)

82'

Jack Harrison (NY City FC)

82'

Jason Hernández (NY City FC)

90'

David Villa (NY City FC)