Columbus Crew - NY City FC

41'

Frank Lampard (NY City FC)

49'

Justin Meram (Columbus Crew)

54'

Tony Taylor (NY City FC)

54'

Jack Harrison (NY City FC)

61'

Héctor Jiménez (Columbus Crew)

61'

Waylon Francis (Columbus Crew)

69'

Ronald Matarrita (NY City FC)

69'

R.J. Allen (NY City FC)

74'

Cedrick Mabwati (Columbus Crew)

74'

Federico Higuaín (Columbus Crew)

82'

John Mendoza (NY City FC)

82'

Jason Hernández (NY City FC)

83'

David Villa (NY City FC)

85'

Justin Meram (Columbus Crew)

85'

Adam Jahn (Columbus Crew)

90'

Tony Tchani (Columbus Crew)

90'

Ethan Finlay (Columbus Crew)